Thoughts From A New Jerseyan in a New York Subway

Being from northern New Jersey, I always feel a strong urge to convince all the New Yorkers around me that I, too, am a New Yorker. I’m not, of course, but I want them to think that I am. Or at the very least I want them to know that I am not a tourist. I can’t explain why I crave the validation that I will never know if I am receiving; nobody is ever going to come up to me and say, “Hey, you’re from New York!” But nonetheless, I want them to be thinking it. 

I feel this urge to prove that I am a New Yorker even though I am not most acutely when I am in the subway. Maybe this is because I lack a basic understanding of how the subway system works. This is the great flaw in my faux-New Yorker identity, because knowing how to use the subway is an integral part to getting around the city. Maybe it is because the subway epitomizes all the gritty, disgustingness that has come to make New Yorkers seem tough and cool. Pair either of these with the fact that in the subway I am surrounded by a smattering of both true New Yorkers and clueless tourists and you have the root of my New Jersey-induced insecurities. I look to the New Yorkers as they stand staring at their cell phones or just generally looking bored to death, undisturbed by the strange smells and the rat-the-size-of-two-normal-sized-rats scurrying across the tracks beneath them, and then to the large Midwestern family behind them loudly trying to decipher a map as they clutch onto oversized backpacks and adjust their baseball caps. I stand to the side, staring at the gray, oddly-stained wall across the tracks, put on my best “I’m used to all this” face, and think, I may not actually live in New York, but I know to avoid Time’s Square at all costs. Don’t mistake me for one of the “them!”

My cover is blown the second anybody asks me for directions. Of course, it is not my New Jersey heritage that prevents me from understanding the subway system - plenty of Garden State natives can get around it just fine - but it is glaring evidence that I am not a New Yorker. It is in that moment that I realize; while I may prefer to spend my time in the city walking around quiet areas of Williamsburg and have no plans to ever visit the tourist-infected Statue of Liberty, I can’t avoid the fact that I hail from the armpit of America, and that’s okay. Besides - that statue’s on our side of the river anyway. 

Comments

Popular Posts